Glock 19 Gen 5 vs 19X: Which Combat Pistol Reigns Supreme?

Overview of the Glock 19 Gen 5 & 19X:

At Paramount Defense LLC, a gun shop in Downingtown, we’re here to break down the key differences between the Glock 19 Gen 5 vs 19x to help you choose the right fit. We will go into detail later, but for now, it is best to understand these two pistols and what differentiates them from one another.

Glock 19 Gen 5 – The Ultimate Compact Handgun:

The Glock 19 Gen 5 is the latest variation of Glock’s best-selling model. The G19’s reputation comes from its balance of size and capability.
As with all Glocks, this compact handgun has a standard 15-round magazine and an extensive list of upgrades for the Gen 5 model. Gen 5 improvements also feature removing finger grooves, the marksman barrel of better accuracy, and an ambidextrous slide stop, improving comfort for all users.
We love the G19 Gen 5’s effectiveness during concealed carry and everyday use. The gun is easily concealable and gives the wielder enough grip for adequate control. It really is a “Goldilocks” gun – not too big or small.

Some improvements in the G5 include:

• Flared magwell for easier, quicker reloads
• Front slide serrations for easier trigger manipulation
• Smoother pull trigger
• Marksman barrel for better accuracy
• nDLC finish for better durability

Glock 19X – The Hybrid Combat Handgun:

The Glock 19X does things differently. Its slide length is the same as that of the compact Glock 19, but its frame is the full-size frame of the Glock 17. This makes it a hybrid that is mostly made for the military and law enforcement.
The 19X was Glock’s response to the U.S. Army’s Modular Handgun System (MHS) competition. Although Sig ultimately won the contract, Glock chose to sell the 19X to civilians, who have embraced the weapon.

Check out all the features it offers:

• Full-size grip for better control
• 17+1 magazine capacity out of the box
• Comes with both 17 and 19-round magazines
• Mil-spec features and coloration

The 19X is best suited for duty use, home defense, or range shooting. It prioritizes die-hard shooting ability over concealment.

Glock 19 Gen 5 vs 19X – Spec Comparison:

Here’s a detailed breakdown of the Glock 19X vs 19 Gen 5 to help you compare their features side by side and see which one better fits your needs:

Glock 19X vs. Glock 19 Gen 5 – Key Differences:

When comparing the Glock 19X vs Glock 19 Gen 5, key differences in design, size, and performance set them apart for different types of shooters. The following are the details you need to know:

1. Size & Ergonomics:

The G19 Gen 5 packs a compact grip suitable for various hands. The removal of finger grooves was a welcome change for many shooters who found them uncomfortable.
The G19X offers a longer grip because the G17’s frame has been extended. Shooters with larger hands prefer this additional area to hold. The extra grip length increases the height by ½ inches.
Both models have the same-length slides, so the sight radius and barrel length remain unchanged. This means they will have similar accuracy potential.

2. Concealed Carry Suitability:

The G19 Gen 5 has the greatest concealed carry capability. The smaller grip means less chance of printing (showing through clothing). The grip is the most difficult part of a pistol to conceal, and the G19 takes care of that problem with its compact grip.
The G19X’s longer grip makes concealment more difficult, especially with light clothing. While possible with the right holster, it lacks the versatility of its compact counterpart.
In this case, the G19 Gen 5 is the clear winner regarding concealment.

3. Performance & Shootability:

The G19X is great in handling and recoil management. The longer grip helps you gain better control and control muzzle flips during rapid fire, making follow-up shots easier.
The G19 Gen 5 is also good, considering its overall size, but the smaller grip provides less leverage against recoil. Still, many shooters with the proper technique find the difference to be minimal.
Both pistols use the same Gen 5 barrel, which means their accuracy potential remains the same. The limiting factor for hitting targets is the user, not the firearm.

4. Magazine Compatibility:

Be careful in this area. The G19 Gen 5 uses Gen 5 mags without the quarter-mouth cutout in the front. This redesign improves reliability but creates several compatibility issues.
The G19X uses Gen 4-style magazines with a front lip. These two models have issues that prevent mag swapping. Keep this in mind if you already own other Glocks and mags.

5. Color & Aesthetics:

The G19 Gen 5 has the classic black finish that all Glocks have.
The G19X’s unique tan color, officially called “Coyote Brown,” gives it a military look. It’s not just for looks; the nPVD coating is designed to withstand harsh conditions.
Some shooters hate how the tan looks, while others prefer it over classic black. Overall, it’s a matter of personal taste!

Common Glock 19 Gen 5 & 19X Problems (And Fixes):

No gun is perfect, and when it comes to the Glock 19X vs Glock 19 Gen 5, here are some issues owners have reported.

Glock 19 Gen 5 Issues:

1. Magazine Well Fitment: A few users claim the Gen 5 magazines are too loose.
   Fix: Aftermarket baseplates can help provide a tighter fit. Otherwise, factory Glock magazines would be best for fit and reliability.
2. Coating Wear: The nDLC finish, although enhanced, can still show wear with heavy use.
   Fix: Regular upkeep helps. If you care about looks, cerakoting is a solution after much use and wear.

Glock 19X Issues:

1. Magazine Lip Issues: Due to lip design, some aftermarket magazines will not be accepted by the 19X.
   Solution: Use Gen 4 magazines or aftermarket ones specifically designed for the 19X.
2. No Front Serrations: The 19X has no front slide serrations like on the Gen 5.
   Solution: If front press checks are a priority, add them with aftermarket slide work. Otherwise, use a different technique for press checking.

Frequently Asked Questions:

1. Can I use Glock 19 Gen 5 mags in a 19X?

No, the 19X uses a Gen 4 magazine design with the front lip, which isn’t compatible with Gen 5 magazines.

2. Which is better for duty use?

The 19X has advantages for duty use with its full-size grip and higher-capacity magazines. However, many law enforcement officers also successfully use the G19 Gen 5.

3. Does the 19X come in a MOS configuration?

No, Glock doesn’t offer the 19X with factory optics cuts. If you want to mount a red dot, you’ll need aftermarket slide milling.

4. Is the 19X just a Gen 5 with a different frame?

Not exactly. While it shares some Gen 5 features, like the improved barrel, it lacks others, like the flared mag well and front serrations.

Final Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?

Choose the Glock 19 Gen 5 if:

• Concealed carry is your primary use
• You want the most versatile option
• You prefer the latest Glock innovations
• You want factory optics-ready options
• You have smaller or medium-sized hands

The G19 Gen 5 is still considered a gold standard for having a do-everything pistol. Its size allows for effective shooting while still being easy to carry.

Choose the Glock 19X if:

• You want a duty or home defense pistol
• You have larger hands
• You prefer the increased capacity
• You like the distinctive tan color
• Concealment isn’t your main concern

The 19X provides improved control and a larger capacity, while relatively small compared to the full-size options.
Both pistols provide the legendary Glock reliability. Either choice gives you a top-tier handgun that will serve you well for years.

Still trying to decide?

Firearm selections are personal choices, which is why at Paramount Defense LLC, a gun shop in Downingtown, we have both of these Glock models available. Our firearms specialists will assist you in selecting a firearm that is tailor-made for you.
We are always there if you need more parameters or even professional tips on the correct add-ons. Shop online at Paramount Defense LLC to see the offerings, talk to the staff directly, and select your suitable Glock.